Gray Days and Gold: Best of 2023
Hello, friends. In this era of beatmakers ruling supreme, it’s easy to find lamentations online about elements of songwriting that, for myriad reasons, have effectively been killed off in today’s popular music: key changes, variances in tempo, any sense of airiness or musicians together in a room, dynamic range…not to mention a decent tune. Thing is, there’s a whole class of artists for whom those ingredients never went out of style—artists often operating away from the limelight, underground like wild potatoes. That’s who we love to celebrate here at Gray Days and Gold, using our iridescent paisley trowel to unearth treasures from the private Idahos of dimly-lit Bandcamp pages.
As always, there’s no ranking and rating in my year-end list. Every artist featured on the show in the past year is someone I’ve considered extraordinary, and there are many excellent albums, EPs and singles that aren’t represented here. These are just the artists whose work, for entirely subjective reasons, found me reaching the end and immediately hitting Play again from the top, eager to spend more time in the sonic worlds they’d created. (If I detect a theme emerging in this year’s picks, it’s music that exuded warmth and comfort.)
So let the brass bands play and feet start to pound—it’s the Gray Days and Gold Best of 2023, accompanied by a playlist on Spotify and Apple Music. For the sake of variety, I’ve mostly chosen different tracks than the ones originally featured on the monthly episodes of the show.
If you like what you hear, there’s all of this and much more in the archives. More importantly, please consider supporting the artists; you’ll find buy links to all the releases below.
Also included are links to the only other Best Of that I consider worthwhile: Chris Evans’s The Curve Ball (broadcasting weekly on Cannock Chase Radio in the UK), which manages to play all the excellent left-field, uncategorizable music that my monthly schedule simply doesn’t find time for. (And no kidding, this is the first year that I didn’t even look at the major music magazines’ Best Ofs. What’s the point?)
Gray Days and Gold: Best of 2023
The Clientele — I Am Not There Anymore • BUY
Long a favorite, I was bound to love any new music by this London group—but I wasn’t expecting a complete reinvention of their sound spurred by Alasdair MacLean’s newfound explorations of sampling and home recording technology. (Lest you think that implies something dully mechanical, rest assured—this is someone who thinks to use these tools to make recordings of the wind, then transcribe that for strings.) The result is an exciting triumph, their best album yet.
Bly Wallentine — nearly everything they released • BUY
That’s right, I couldn’t be bothered to pick just one among the eight singles and EPs Bly’s released this past year, because in aggregate there’s a full album’s worth of songs that are all worth hearing. Stylistically Bly knows no bounds and even on the sporadic occasions when a track is dressed in a fashion that might not be immediately up my alley (electropop, for example) I always return to it a little later and realize how amazing the song is. A remarkable, utterly unique artist.
Yael Hayem — Spot the Difference • BUY
Few phenomena surprise and delight me more than someone who seemingly comes out of nowhere to land on my year-end list. I’m astonished by the sophistication and individuality in this Boston artist’s debut, especially in light of her admission that she hadn’t per se been intending to make an album before sitting down in July to record some songs that had amassed. A remarkable talent.
I’mdifficult 我是機車少女 • BUY
It’s rare for me to find modern “sophistipop” that isn’t mere style over substance, but this Taiwanese group’s long-awaited debut album hits it out of the park with requisite dreamy atmosphere and smooth grooves combined with top-notch, deeply personal tunesmithery.
theCatherines — Wanna Meet Our Neighbours? • BUY
For a year and a half Heiko Schneider had been releasing songs in piecemeal fashion, but it wasn’t until they came together in this album about the places, characters and history of his Hamburg neighborhood that I grasped the enormity of his vision and the superlative quality of his timeless pop songwriting. A charming DIY masterpiece.
Holly Henderson — The Walls • BUY
Apart from the fact they both hail from Kent, UK, I’ve no idea why Henderson’s second album should remind me so much of Kate Bush’s early KT Bush Band. I don’t assume she made a conscious decision to channel mid-70s British folk/pop, but she’s brilliantly captured the organic warmth of musicians playing live in an intimate setting, which perfectly suits these songs about the nature of home during the pandemic years. Simply put, no other album this year made me feel as good as this one does; it gets right inside and makes me sway back and forth. As Kate sang, warm and soothing.
Grimson — Climbing Up the Chimney • BUY
Written between 2013–2017 and with individual songs materializing more than two years in advance of the album, this Berlin-based New Yorker’s debut record was a long time coming but unquestionably worth the wait. Exquisitely crafted and, like many of this year’s selections, drawing on the sort of dynamic songwriting more associated with previous decades, this is the emergence of a wonderful new artist.
Sternpost — Ulrika • BUY
The solo project of Testbild!’s Petter Herbertsson is full of the impeccable, cosmic, shimmering chamber pop that’s his speciality, and I would want nothing else. Swoonworthy even for non-Swedish-speakers.
[Only available on Bandcamp, so missing from the playlist.]
NIIKA — Still a Soft One • BUY
With arrangements that feature little more than the Russian-born, Chicago-based singer and her guitar, this languid EP is still full of intriguing melodic and compositional twists, gorgeous harmonies, and an enveloping warmth that leaves me eager for more.
Novelty Island — Wallsend Weekend Television • BUY
Remember all those elements missing from modern pop music, as mentioned in my introductory note? Look no further—they’re alive, well, and abundant in spades in the second album of restless retro pop by Liverpool-based Tom McConnell. Markedly more dynamic and fun than the material on his 2021 debut, it would be easy to perceive this album as a great leap forward when, in fact, these tracks were recorded first but shelved until now. And while he wears his early-70s influences on his sleeve, his songwriting is so strong as to escape any accusations of pastiche. Indeed, in my opinion he’s writing modern classics that deserve to be covered by artists fifty years from now.
Ellen Tsai — Strings at Sea • BUY
Following up last year’s Strings on Land EP, the Florida-based, self-trained chamber composer returns with an EP inspired by oceanic adventure. I’m always knocked out by the mastery in her work and all too eager to sing her praises.
Farmer — Spring • BUY
London-based Mike Farmer is a one-man MIDI orchestra, weaving incredible, densely-packed song cycles full of repeating motifs. His latest is a prog-pop wonderland in which the everything-plus-the-kitchen-sink arrangements never outshine the relatable humanity at the songs’ heart.
Monster Furniture — Giant Egg • BUY
An exuberantly-orchestrated outing from Brooklyn-based Gabe Smoller, the album explores the topics of isolation and connection via a narrative about a “quest to meet an animal in an enormous floating terrarium filled only with fossils.” Irresistible.
Brendan Eder Ensemble — Therapy • BUY
Inspired by the liminality between spiritual and physical realms, with a dose of Aphex Twin thrown in, I’m inclined to describe this Angeleno’s latest album with the word Eno-esque in that the spines of these compositions themselves aren’t necessarily complex—many tracks are built on a simple looping pattern—but what’s mesmerizing is the way that orchestral instruments appear, ebb, flow and interact in a gossamer, ever-changing display, like a sunrise painted with woodwinds, horns and harp.
Quincey May Brown — Basic Surgeon • BUY
The debut solo album by this Manchester songwriter and harpist is a darkly humorous delight, the quietly exquisite arrangements allowing her distinctive lyrical eviscerations to stand forcefully in the spotlight. An artist like no other.
Rachael Lavelle — Big Dreams • BUY
That voice, almost otherworldly like something emerged from the mists of a forest primeval, nestled within an ethereal pillow of electronics and organic instrumentation while commenting on modern culture with the driest of wit… there’s much to love in the debut album by this Dublin artist.
Rasmus Dahl — Unearth • BUY
This young Danish artist has created a breathtaking work of orchestral songwriting, best appreciated in its entirety.
Alex Pester — Better Days • BUY
Bath, UK-based Pester has always worn his heart on his artistic sleeve, and on this album that heart is clearly broken. The mood is blue and introspective, but his melodies are superb and his writing, arranging and production abilities more skillful than ever. Witness the sublime melancholy of the track I’ve chosen for this playlist, “So What?” (a stinging reply to the album’s previous track, “You Love Me”).
Michael R. Oldham — Absent-Minded Romance • BUY
Containing seven brief solo piano miniatures totaling barely over 15 minutes, this wisp of an album by Chicago-based Oldham is simply perfect in its evocative, romantic melancholy.
This Is the Kit — Careful of Your Keepers • BUY
Few artists have such instinct for mining the unexpected from seemingly simple ingredients as does Paris-based Kate Stables. Always essential.
Babi — Hana Furu Hi • BUY
When not composing for video games, commercials and soundtracks, Japanese artist Babi finds time to make an occasional album of kinetic, joyous, endlessly inventive songs full of sonic surprises. Guaranteed to put a smile on your face.
Lucinda Chua — YIAN • BUY
An examination of identity and dis/connection to cultural heritage, delivered in such an intimate hush that it’s almost like an internal monologue. Captivating and transportive, this seems like her most vulnerable and assured work yet.
Westerman — An Inbuilt Fault • BUY
Sounding not dissimilar from late-period Talk Talk—but without the uncompromising minimalism—Athens-based Will Westerman has crafted a beautifully textured, introspective album from pandemic-era isolation and dread.
Laura Groves — Radio Red • BUY
A companion piece of sorts to Holly Henderson’s album in that both artists’ adherence to bygone standards of songcraft seem to make their work spring from another time and leave me feeling as if I’ve been listening to this music all my life. Intimate, comforting, beautiful.
Pneumatic Tubes — Petits Bleus • BUY
A beautifully pastoral album of meditative flute and clarinet improvisations by Denton, TX-based Jesse Chandler, many recorded al fresco, embellished with overdubs to add depth and harmony. I almost didn’t include this in my list, second-guessing that some listeners might find the concept too lacking in variety to possibly warrant the nod, but I have the greatest respect for Chandler’s musical instincts and can listen to this collection on repeat without ever tiring of it.
[Only available on Bandcamp, so missing from the playlist.]
Rosie Miles — Still Life • BUY
Despite being about life put on hold during the pandemic, the debut EP by this Leeds songwriter is a supremely confident stride into the arena, her stunning voice accompanied by lush, jazz-inflected arrangements.
See also: The Curve Ball Top 30 Albums of 2023
Chris Evans’s choices are always worth a listen. Check out his three-part roundup, or at least review the master list.
- Part 1: Entries 30–21 • Mixcloud • Playlist
- Part 2: Entries 20–11 • Mixcloud • Playlist
- Part 3: Entries 10–1 • Mixcloud • Playlist
Happy new year, and I look forward to more music discoveries with you in 2024. If you have questions, suggestions, opinions, etc. please feel free to contact me. And if you’d like to receive these posts via email, you can sign up below.